3 thoughts on “Oil exports, “unknown region” and trade balances

  1. This is a top piece of work, Mr Whyte. Many thanks.

    Some of the output you quote from the Scottish Government is most unsettling. Firstly, there is that misleading explanation of the ‘unknown region’. Then there is that stuff about possible depreciation of sterling as a result of Brexit – completely ignoring the fact that depreciation of a currency has a substantial upside, which is that it boosts exporters and indigenous manufacturers and producers (which is why both China and Norway (for example) both game the system to keep their currencies low; and which is why the British economy rebounded so spectacularly after the pound fell off a cliff against the DM on Black Wednesday). It really is economics 101, but whoever’s producing this stuff either doesn’t know that (possible), or is deliberately trying to deceive those who don’t know economics 101 into thinking that a depreciation of a currency is automatically some kind of disaster. Whatever the case, it stinks.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Fraser … having posted on Common Space (CS) about these issues, I was eventually directed here and offer my thanks for the work you have put into this, I have only scanned so far, but even that has proved helpful, and I think corrective of my post on CS … which at its heart (irrespective of political perspective) was about the need for accurate and verifable data, which allows for the debates on the subjects which confront us in Scotland.


    1. Hi Mike, I appreciate the comment

      I would agree that the data, such as it has been attempted to be used, would benefit from some clarity – particularly on the recent evidenceless claims about how much of Scotland’s exports to rUK then go straight on to the EU.

      However I’d argue that the onus for providing this clarity lies with those who are seeking constitutional change. In much the same way that ScotGov would not feel the need to provide data on ‘exports’ between Grampian and Lothian, so there’s no real requirement for UKGov to quantify ‘exports’ from Scotland to Wales.

      Again, I appreciate your comment.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s